Sunday, November 15, 2026

393. Pigs in a Polka (1943)

Release Date: February 2nd, 1943

Series: Merrie Melodies

Director: Friz Freleng

Story: Mike Maltese

Animation: Dick Bickenbach

Musical Direction: Carl Stalling

Starring: Mel Blanc (Wolf, Third Pig), Sara Berner (First and Second Pigs)

You can watch it here, or on Tubi (S:10 E:02, segment 3!)

As repeatedly alluded to in prior reviews, 1943 is a particularly significant year where the rapid growth and expansion of the studio's cartoons reaches full culmination. The shorts don't feel as locked in a limbo of transition anymore--the metaphorical feet are on the equally metaphorical pavement, and it's a matter of taking off. Coal Black being the first short of the year certainly scores such themes of entering with a bang.

That's continued with Friz Freleng's Pigs in a Polka--its own bang was big enough to warrant an Oscar nomination. It comes just a little over a year after his last Oscar nomination for Rhapsody in Rivets which, just like this short, places steadfast focus on musical spectacle.

Intriguingly, Polka's production number--MM-17-12, 8565--is sandwiched between Jack Wabbit and the Beanstalk and Yankee Doodle Daffy, which released in June and July respectively. Polka's February release hints that it was rushed to release. A phenomenon not new to Warner's, as a handful of Bugs cartoons were rushed through production following the success of A Wild Hare's release, particularly Elmer's Pet Rabbit. It doesn't seem far-fetched to speculate that Polka's rush release was to squeeze into the voting window for the Oscars.

Such a factoid is telling in itself of Polka's prestige. Viewing it does yield a rather Oscar nomination-worthy cartoon; its meticulosity and lavishness and sense of spectacle, even (or especially) if it harbors a sardonic edge to it, is very much felt. Just the same, that may be symptomatic of what it's spoofing: both Disney's Fantasia and The Three Little Pigs are subject to equal burlesque in this sardonic mash of the two, the latter fairytale ardently timed to Brahms' Hungarian Dances.

This would be the first of two Fantasia spoofs released in 1943 under the Warner label, with the other being Bob Clampett's A Corny Concerto. Both cartoons are relatively independent within themselves, each strongly reflective of their respective directors' habits and tastes, but are bound in musical accordance and theming to warrant comparison. That's a topic more fitting for the review of the latter, so as not to spoil its contents here, but does deserve mention nonetheless. There's the Freleng way of the Fantasia method and the Clampett way. Today, we examine the former.

The Freleng way, as is a thesis with most of his cartoons, is blunt and mischievously cynical. No frills, no fluff--just a bludgeon of objectivity that stings with its dry, impish humor. Perhaps this is no better displayed than the cartoon's opening: the camera fades up to reveal the wolf, already dressed like Deems Taylor, already in position, orchestra at the ready and finishing their introductory coda of Brahm's Dances. Rather than the slow, careful, and gratuitous introductions seen in Fantasia, respectfully giving each segment its say and bestowing thoughtful diatribes to even the musical instruments themselves, Freleng's introduction is more comparable to stumbling into a random room by complete accident with eerily stark timing. 

Any visual fluff we do receive is just a matter of picking up where it was implied we left off: a curt but gregarious squint-grin at the audience from the wolf, and a moment dedicated to putting on his glasses in pursuit of completing the Deems Taylor aesthetic. His bright yellow gloves keep them clear and distinguishes against the white of the paper and his suit, allowing for better visual focus. The since-warmed up orchestra finishes their practice accordingly. When the music starts over from the beginning, it's no longer for a practice run.

Freleng's bluntness is very understated--that's what makes it funny. We've already seen Fantasia. There's no need to run through it again. Freleng trusts us to get the joke, and that he doesn't need to intrude by spoon-feeding us information. There's a certain knowingness to the wolf's coy smile at the audience for all of the one second it appears; that's about all the acknowledgement Freleng needs of his metatextual humor.

"Ladies an' gentlemen--tonight it gives me extreme pleasuh to announce our interpreta... intrepi... in..."

If this wolf were to possess any shred of credibility and poise, all of that comes crashing down as a nasally, Brooklyn-laced Blancian dialect drawls out of the wolf's mouth, faltering only to completely butcher the pronunciation of his script. Deems Taylor, this is not. This guy can't even fake his way through correctly. In just this simple moment, any prestige and respect in accordance to the source material comes crashing down. Disney did it their way. Warner's will do it their way, as brashly and with as much playful disrepect--but still some semblance of respect--as possible.

At the same time, this is the wolf from the story. This is the extent of his dialogue that we hear, as the story itself is conveyed through almost all music, but it is the same wolf--thus, this butchering of decorum feels in character for the cartoon's villain. This rubelike, rag wearing, pig feasting brute can't be expected to give a respectful seminar.

"...T-E-R-P... in-toi-puh-tay-shun of a fuhmiliar fairy tale entitled da Big Bad Wolf..."

The eponymous wolf pauses for dramatic effect, looking straight into the audience, allowing the grandiosity of his title to sink in.

"...an'at'reelittlepigs."

Polka is another in the genre of "Freleng Wolf" cartoons that were particularly concentrated in the early-to-mid '40s. The voice, the clear disingenuousness of his act, and even clearer embrace of ego all harken back to efforts such as The Trial of Mr. Wolf--especially with the fourth wall breaking in hopes of endearing oneself to the audience. Through these elements alone the wolf conveys a very clear and amusing personality. Almost moreso than he actually exhibits in the body of the cartoon, as that is almost framed as him playing a bit part. Here is his chance to endear himself to the public, knowing that eyes are on him. His chance to make a good name for himself before we view his debauchery against the three little pigs, who are barely worthy enough in his eyes to receive a credit. As Freleng-esque as this wolf and his personality is, this meta framing and self awareness in the wolf's role and personality is decidedly Maltese-ian, who is indeed our writer for the short.

More verbal butchering ensues as the wolf introduces "Joe-hannus Brams" and his Hungarian Dances. That, too, connotes a playful lack of disrespect and disregard; Deems Taylor wouldn't be caught dead assaulting the names in his own wordy and eloquent introductions. It's not that Freleng things Brahms isn't deserving of a proper pronunciation--it's just that this wolf is a rube. Attempts to establish this short as the anti-Fantasia are swift and clear.

"As da scene opens, we fin' da t'ree little pigs building dere respective houses..."

A fade out-and-back-in to black is the transition of choice between the opening wraparound and the body of the cartoon. Perhaps a cross dissolve would be the more typical choice, as the transition between ideas isn't obstructed by very much--no need to do a hard "reset" for clarity. However, the fade to black does feel contextually appropriate, if only in an aesthetic sense. It mimics the feeling of lights going down in favor of the show starting. Likewise, it's faithful to the original Fantasia format and its transitions between segments.

Freleng's penchant for crystal clear, no nonsense, no frills set-ups continue as the metaphorical lights rise on one of the pigs preparing to build his house. Both the prominent sheet of instructions--accompanied by visual diagrams, no less--and the obtusely labeled "PRE-FABRICATED STRAW HOUSE" embrace a comic curtness with the readiness of the presentation. 

Just the same, and more cognizantly, all of this precise planning and coy readiness of materials offers a modernistic spin on the old fairytale. Even something as barebones as a straw house is subject to the modern convenience and invention of ready-made kits and flashy visual instructions. This fairytale is modern, streamlined, a comfortable product of the war era and its proud embrace of manufacturing.

And, in case we don't get it, the pig--also riding on the coattails of convenience--literally explains his role to us: "I'm the little pig that builds my house of straw!"

Sara Berner lends her voice to this pig and the next, putting on her best cutesy, squeaky voice. Her vocals here fill the niche that Berneice Hansell filled in the mid-late '30s; vocals so coy they teeter on the edge of grating, but deployed so with a purposeful sardonicism. Just the same, Berner's performance doesn't completely reek of irony--it can be accepted straight, if so desired, but knowing the combined sensibilities of Freleng and Maltese's sense of humor, the triteness is the point. Especially with the equally trite spoon-feeding of dialogue.

Dick Bickenbach is cast for this sequence, and delivers accordingly. Even in this mundane close-up shot of the pig talking, the movement and energy is youthful, spritely, the drawings appealing through solid construction and little aesthetic details--the shine in the eyes, the wrinkles on the cheeks. He can elevate a serviceable little cut like this one, and easily rise to the challenge of a scene that demands more precarious timing and energy. Such is the case of the ensuing shot.

Pig #1 acts on his word and builds his house accordingly. "Hungarian Dance No. 5" is our first selection of dances, and could not be inaugurated by a better animated fit--Bickenbach's timing has always been especially sharp in the Freleng shorts, regardless of circumstance, but a cartoon that's as tightly wound as this one by it's own timing certainly benefits from a figure such as him. His animation feels lithe, breezy, not necessarily constrained by the demands of the timing but in a comfortable equilibrium. 


A stake is planted into the ground on each main beat of the introduction. The act of the pig stabbing the stake into the ground calls direct attention to the beat, which jabs forward in the music; the action both responds to and conducts the music. Movement between the stakes to the next place is primarily conducted through drybushing and multiples, all timed on ones, again contributing that breeziness that keeps the viewer focused on which beats demand accentuation and not getting distracted by filler.

Obviously, the novelty of the action so strictly compliant to the music is the biggest draw, but it isn't the only draw. There are still some aesthetic and just-for-fun flourishes sprinkled throughout; when the pig raises the wire spokes in preparation to open like an umbrella, Carl Stalling accents this action with a very faint "ding!" in the score--something to differentiate the action and offer a feeling of progression.

A weathervane sprouts out of the umbrella-esque foundation; a completely arbitrary and, because of that, completely funny addition. Another embrace of this short's coy modernism through details both big and small.

The ritual of putting in the stakes is somewhat mirrored by the pig now dragging a wire mesh across each stake--again, more modernity, more foundation, and more laughs through the meticulousness and arbitrariness of the process... but, really, to keep the flow of the music going. 

An additional minor note of aesthetic appreciation: the cluster of flowers in the foreground is diagonally parallel to the tree in the top left corner, both objects framing the composition and boxing the audience's eye into the center. Likewise, the fuchsia of the flowers maintains color harmony with the pink hills in the background, again unifying the composition. All of the above very subtle but nonetheless purposeful touches.

Getting back to the topic of flow, it's maintained in spades through a rapid cut to the pig pitching the hay onto the foundation. In one shot, he's still dragging the wire to the last stake. In the very next frame, he's already got his pitchfork in hand and is making a dash for the hay. It happens so quickly and so smoothly that the audience has no time to register any errors in hook-ups; this is a unique privilege offered by this short's strict adherence to the music. Little details like that can be fudged due to the understanding and also "distraction" of musical timing--it feels right, and that's what matters.

Bickenbach's animation of the pig's pitching is admirably rapid; the smears and multiples and drybrushing all certainly pull their hand in furthering the illusion of quickness, but the drawings and timing itself--all on one's--are just as pivotal. Likewise with the camera pushing in on the pig, furthering the illusion of increasing momentum via claustrophobia. Already Freleng and his animators have doubled their knack for speed in the time since Rhapsody in Rivets, which was already a pretty deft and speedy cartoon for its time. This, however, is untouchable momentum.

It's especially powerful when coupled by an immediate inverse. With the music resolving, the frantic strings melting into a resolution chord, our pitching porcine follows suit: with equal fervency he rushes to luxuriate, the brief silence in music deafening against the action before it. All that hard work was merely in service of resting faster.

Interestingly, there's no big fuss about a proper reveal of the hay hut: the actual end result is incidental, again in favor of the pig rushing to his rest. The finished product humbly resides in the backdrop. Comparatively brighter objects surrounding the pig's respite--the bright fuchsia chair, but also the even brighter flowers calling attention to that corner of the screen--shift the attention. Not enough to miss the coy, fun detail of the houseplants outside the door being made of hay, too, another extension of the short's tongue-in-cheek modernity.

With #1 one-and-done, focus swiftly shifts to #2, who, like #1, is a chipper, squeaky drone to the story. Same voice, same writing ("I'm the little pig that builds my house out of sticks!"), marginally different building materials to match the marginally different clothing--both being the closest semblance to individuality these two pigs have. They seem completely fine with it.

That in itself brings attention to another wonderfully sarcastic detail within the short: all three pigs are branded with their respective numbers accordingly, 1, 2, and 3; just to prevent any profound confusion. It's so obtuse that it wraps right back around to being clever again.

And on the topic of deceitful ideas of cleverness, #2's ideal house receives the same coy "subversion" as #1--his house of sticks is made specifically out of matchsticks. All the more modern and all the more impractical than a regular stick house would be. It isn't even the matchsticks that receive visual focus (at this point), but their matchboxes--bright blue boxes of modern convenience to specifically drive this idea of irrationality and modernity home. 

The somewhat vacant stare, occasionally prominent teeth, and splayed fingers on the hands peg Gil Turner as a likely candidate for the animator. While his animation can have a tendency to be on the aimless and floaty side--something that's been locked down in recent years--he's still extremely dutiful to the musical timing as #2 builds his own matchstick house.

#1 and #2 are deliberate parallels of each other, but their means of building their houses differ, even beyond building materials. There's no foundation laid out here as there was for #1. Each match is placed accordingly to the music, consisting of a relatively slow and deliberate operation for a stretch of time--then, when the music flourishes, that's reflected in the acting with multiple matches placed at once. 

Occasionally at impossible intervals, too: the matches at the top of the soon-to-be-doorway hang in their comfortable impossibility before being supported by the rest from the ground-up. But, again, the improbability of physics isn't as much of a focus as maintaining visual interest and, most importantly, ardent anchoring to the music.

Slow is again differentiated by fast, with much of the remaining construction executed through multiples and puffs of smoke. All in the name of maintaining visual interest and differentiating it from the ritual of #1, which extends to the music having some slightly different flourishes this time around. Both pigs' building rituals similar enough to be a parallel, but not exact enough to bore through repetition.

Pig #2's outcome is certainly the opposite of #1's: the final finishing touch--just one single match--prompts this meticulously drawn and built haven of matchsticks to tumble to the ground.

...which, when thought about for 2 seconds, is the complete and logical outcome. How could anything but this be the outcome? Nevertheless, the confidence and pattern seeking of Freleng's direction lulls the audience into a false sense of security. Surely this house will somehow hold, because it melds to the music with such purpose. That too is another Freleng staple, lulling the audience into accepting the asinine, only to rug-pull with a bludgeon of objective reality at the last minute. It's very well done here, especially with Pig #1 to compare to. A hearty kudos to Turner, his assistants, and the ink and paint team for having to painstakingly animate every single match, built and toppled.

A diagonal wipe transition separates all three pigs from one another. This time, the transition wipes in the opposite direction, giving the feeling of progression and avoiding too much repetition between transitions. Fitting, considering the third pig is--per the original story--where things begin to deviate.

"Things" being practicality. The sight of reinforced brick and mortar is a relief after the sights of matchbox houses or straw rush jobs--likewise, he's already in the middle of building the house, much of it cemented to permanence via a painted background. He doesn't wait for our attention nor gratitude to start building. Work is more important.

"I'm the smart little pig--" In addition to the deviation of syntax from the established pattern, this self-imposed genus is also voiced by Mel Blanc rather than Sara Berner to mark the differences further. "I build my house of bricks!"

He kindly takes time from his busy schedule to demonstrate. To further embrace his rationality, the staging and execution of his methodology is comparatively no frills. Still impressively timed to the music, but rationally--mortar spread, bricks stacked accordingly in order, no physics defied nor spruces of modernity. The staging is very objective; not exactly flat, but, again, no frills. There to get the job done. It's not a lack of inspiration on Freleng's part as it is serviceable to the pig's rational work. The bright blue color card for the sky contrasts well with the bright crimson bricks.

Any frills that do arrive are not from the pig or self imposed, but nature itself: the camera suddenly pans over to reveal a stork lethargically lounging in a nearby nest. Storks would serve as a recurring theme in some of Freleng's later cartoons, especially with his character of the drunk stork; perhaps this is the first domino to fall.

This stork is no drunk. Simply a spectator. The trees frame him nicely, negative space clear and open, the dark green of the leaves juxtaposing against the bright blue skies. He still manages to adhere to the general rhythm of the scene--what little there is, as the music isn't as involved as it once had been--but to the barest minimum degree. 

His commentary arrives in some insightfully dull lip smacks.

And, through that, we return back to the pig. A little non-sequitur that hints to being more through its inclusion at all, it's also funny because it's redundant. It's certainly more effective for the camera to pan matter-of-factly to the stork and back, rather than cutting away entirely; keeping that little link back to the scene at hand makes this feel even more like a random, redundant interruption than if there were to be a hard cut--one that'd feel comparatively more disorienting.

Pig #3 shows no concern nor even acknowledgement towards the bird, for that would be time taken away from his work. More bricks are dutifully applied to the mortar, in time with Stalling's slowing, moody music score...

...only to receive a little help from a friend. The slow, lethargic introduction of the stork serves as an antithesis to his sudden re-entry, violent and brash both through the crash of music that arrives with it and the broadness of his actions. It's difficult to see because of how quickly and violently it happens, but freeze framing reveals that the stork lands on top of the pig's head and is responsible for shoving him down, rather than him simply ducking out of the way.


 

The same sleepy, lethargic blinks and lip smacks resume after the nest has been adequately reassembled. A solid bookend that calls even more attention to the violent flurry of action in-between, and the bookend itself as rhythmic as the music. Moreso, even; the music comes to a halt in service of the stork's lip smacks and lethargy. The onslaught of the musical crescendo is more deafening when left to hang over the audience in its absence.

 

With all three pigs' houses complete (or, at least two of them), a little recreation is in order. Freleng's Disney pastiching is no more obvious than in these vignettes of #1 and #2 doing a little musical jig, flute and violin in tow--a very clear jape towards the "Who's Afraid of the Big Bad Wolf?" sequences in the original Disney cartoon. 

Such a vignette exists to be as twee and cloying as humanly (or porcinely) possible. There's no real buildup or reason for it to be included, but that's not a detriment so much as it is a purposeful decision on Freleng's part. It exists to lampoon. That's all the reason it needs. The spontaneity of such an arrangement makes it feel even more redundant, which makes it feel more coy, which is the entire point. 

All of this is furthered in the acting details. The first two "break"s in the music--the chord at the end of each verse--is accented by a cordial bow to one another. Childish, gleeful giggling fills the space where the music picks up afterward...

 

...and is resolved through whatever-this-is.

Despite being so provocatively saccharine, the playful cynicism in intent does not bog down the integrity of the execution itself. Freleng's musical timing remains startlingly on-point, the movements of the pigs exceptionally lithe and airy and anchored to every little bit. It's funny because it's well done. Though being a parody, something of this caliber has equal potential to go horribly awry in the wrong hands, where the tongue-in-cheek-iness of it may not translate and instead come off as genuinely trite--this has certainly been an issue with some cartoons before. 

Freleng commits to the bit in that this little routine doesn't feel slapdash or lazy in its execution, the cynicism not affecting artistic integrity, but it has just the right--and delicate--air of irony to it. A deeply impressive and precarious balance to hit.

Especially when doing so twice over. Freleng repeats the whole spiel over, further driving the redundancy of this action into effect, playing on the repetitive nature of the Disney cartoon's own respective jig. The harmonies in the music are more layered this time, the flute higher pitched, so as not to grate the audience's nerves too much.

Ditto with the camera panning over to reveal #3, still hard at work maintaining his post of practicality. His musical contributions are the scrapes of the hoe in the mortar. The sound effects to begin to fall out of sync ever so slightly towards the end of his vignette, but not enough to topple the overall sequence--his visit is exactly that; a visit. Something to split up the cinematography so the audience isn't too bored by the monotony. The glimpse of #3 grounds the entire sequence, his steely glare and practical workmanship making the other pigs' gallivanting seem all the more juvenile.

A keen, quick, subtle detail: right before the camera cuts to the next act of the cartoon, the pigs' cycle is seen starting over for a third time.

Gallivanting of a different order is studied as we cut to the wolf in his natural habitat: ragged pants, a bowler cap, completely free of his Deems Taylor-esque facade flaunted at the top of the short. Intriguingly, his subversion arrives in the form of being overtly law abiding. He too staunchly abides the rhythm of Hungarian Dance No. 5, dancing a variant of the Hopak as he winds his way along the trail. To break free of the music would breach the novelty of the short completely, but his accordance to the short's structure feels like a meta twist in itself.

More clear in this point of subversion-through-civilty are the turn signals he gives as he rounds each bend. Nobody to follow him, he's idiosyncratically law abiding. There's the coy sense that this is the only area where that applies.

When the music shifts, the wolf's actions do accordingly. He freezes, the music halting with him, a surprised take filling the gap as it's implied he's spotted the pigs. Freleng keeps it economical, refraining from a cut to said pigs--there's no need if the same information can be conveyed through a take, the right eye direction, and the gentle scenery change (the layout now a horizontal camera pan instead of a gentle vertical through the winding woods). Likewise, it keeps the direction consistent and smooth, an easier transition between parts of the song if kept all on one shot.

The slow, anticipatory drag of the strings is matched through the wolf's slow, slinky movements between conveniently spaced trees: a Freleng staple. 

Freleng has been working on this sneak gag for some years now, appearing as early as Porky's Hired Hand, and would have decades to refine it to his needs. It's certainly at its most sharp and lithe at this point in the chronology. Dictated through the music, the action is kept fresh particularly by the jaunty little jog the wolf does in accordance with the burst of staccato notes. It almost feels as though the music were conducted purely to be outfitted with a Freleng cartoon rather than vice versa. The marriage between the action and sound feels so obvious here, but that's not a pejorative, rather than an indictment of how well the two go together.

Novel as the music and action are together, Freleng and Maltese knew that there needs to be some sort of topper or subversion to maintain audience interest. It isn't entirely enough to flaunt the novelty of synchronization just in itself. Such is answered by the wolf plummeting into a nearby pond, his musical routine unaware of the change in scenery--a comedic complacency almost synonymous with Chuck Jones' Coyote cartoons later on.

Yet, rather than lingering on the wolf's ignorance for his surroundings, he adapts. A furtive piano glissando from Stalling hints at some polite dissatisfaction and tribulation on the wolf's end, punctuating his folly, coupled by him gingerly retrieving his hat.

That all melts into a continuation of the same music heard prior, and, with it, the same action: just underwater. The bubbles on the surface communicate where the wolf is underneath, given additional tangibility through Treg Brown's audible bubbling sounds. Stalling's instrumentation is notably more flighty, muted, a frilly, ethereal harp that does amazingly connote the sensation of being underwater.


A note of appreciation for the backgrounds. The airbrushed reflections of the reeds and trees in the water offer a nice juxtaposition to the flat, geometric, and gently abstract blocks of color making up the remaining environments--it seems the stylization inflicting the Jones and McCabe units has rubbed off on the Freleng unit, too.

Approaching land resolves the action; more quick, jubilant tip-toes, the cycle ending for good as the wolf takes cover behind a rock. Said rock is different from a tree or a surprise pond--the advancement in geography also means advancement in story.

Nothing advances a story quite like a good ol' non-sequitur. Years of observing cartoons, directed by Freleng or otherwise, preps the audience to anticipate the wolf peeking out from behind the rock, maw drooling, hands rubbing, eye on the prize of the pigs. Him immediately springing into action, dressed as a Romni, dancing to the opening of Brahms' fifth Hungarian Dance is quite the subversion--both in story and confidence in direction. The tone of the direction is matter-of-fact, secure; if anyone is taken aback by this shift, it's only the audience and the pigs whom the wolf approaches.

The camera continually pans, following the wolf as he approaches the pigs; it's a subtle thing, not make or break, but differentiates this camera pan from the entire sequence prior of the wolf slinking and the camera's start-stop-start-stop momentum. Freleng's direction remains fresh, purposeful and alert.
The camera halts when the pigs are properly centered in the stage, giving greater focus to the gag of their bodies twisting as they haplessly ogle at the wolf. A sight worth ogling at--the smears and arcs on the wolf's circuitous twirls are so eye popping and smooth that it's easy to lose the gag with the pigs. The connective follow through between the tambourine's streamers and the wolf's arced arms marks for a very hypnotic effect, especially when parallel to the action of his skirt.
Freleng essentially repeats the same directorial momentum of the wolf sneaking towards the pigs as he does the wolf luring the wolves: same start, stop, start, stop, same actions and glides and footsteps guided by the music, just in the opposite direction. Nonetheless, it doesn't immediately feel like a retread of the prior sequence. Establishing equilibrium, sure, but the camera cutting between the wolf and the pigs rather than harnessing it all on one continuous shot keeps things fresh. No doubt a purposeful decision.
It's also to uphold the call and response in the music. Wolf timed to one aspect of the beat, the call--pigs timed to the furtive, anxious response. The literality of the synchronicity is integrated into the story well and vice versa.
The fated rock symbolizes a cap on this sequence, as does the camera trucking in rather than over. Ditto with the music coming to an anticipatory crawl. With it, the direction.
Fun anthropomorphization on the tambourine, its streamers beckoning the pigs like a finger. Pigs answer dutifully, anxious footsteps still methodically timed to every beat.
The harsh resolution of the music is equally harsh in the action: dust clouds symbolizing a skirmish of some sort, and the camera suddenly pulling out to capture it, ensnaring an additional feeling of surprise through the sudden movement. Rest assured that the dust clouds are anchored to the music as dutifully as every other action in this cartoon--such an innocuous but incredibly valuable attention to detail.
Freleng and Maltese uphold their themes of subversion by having not the wolf emerge victorious, but the two pigs. With them, the wolf's Romani garb: diklo, röijy, and salbă in tow, the capture in clothing symbolizing their victory over the skirmish. The burst of energy with the dance and the synchronization (innately so, as the drawings are duplicated) practically leap off the screen, helped immensely through the sudden crescendo in music, all effective because of how creeping and slow and furtive the direction was prior. Every high with a low, every up with a down.
Such remains true when the wolf--free of his cultural appropriation--zips in to confront the pigs. The music dies down, the dancing halts, the swine synchronization swindled.
More repeated themes ensue: a call and response in action, of sorts, from each characters--pigs step back, wolf steps forward. Camera in a continuous crawl backwards. Staccato music notes obeyed through plucky, furtive footsteps from the pigs. 
There's a lot of repetition in acting and staging here, but Freleng finds ways to throw on additional details or change up the shot flow (where possible) or throw in the aforementioned highs and lows in-between to keep it interesting. None of this action reads as just "the wolf goes right, then left, and then eventually left again". It's more than that, kept alive through the subtle details and especially the synchronization in music, which is the real selling point of this entire cartoon. Freleng is able to get away with little "cheats" and repetition in staging in service of visually scoring the music. It's a luxury few other cartoons can boast.

Likewise, this sequence ends in quite the bang: the wolf and pigs jumping up at the same time, the 1-2 beat of the pigs zipping off-screen, and the wolf left to pick up the slack, all while the pigs' clothing is still falling to the ground, is certainly visually and directorially distinct from the aforementioned patterns. The break in the paradigm makes this burst of energy feel much more powerful.
And, reminding us of the cartoon's roots, pig #1 and #2 seek shelter in their straw abode (which amazingly doesn't topple to the ground upon the slam of the wooden door.)
That's taken care of through other means.

A fantastically blunt topper. It's surprising, it's harsh, and it makes sense through not making sense. There's the playful pseudo-indication that the wolf received the match from pig #2's failed architecture, but it's moreso aligned with the philosophies expounded upon at the top of the review: this short is comparatively modern. Blueprints and kits are used to build houses. The pigs are complacent and knowing in their roles. That doesn't end with the wolf; huffing and puffing is so 1933. Knowing all of this, we shouldn't be surprised that the wolf burns their house down, but we are anyway.
It works through the no-nonsense of Freleng's direction. To demonstrate a big, flashy sequence of the wolf retrieving and lighting the match would kill what makes this funny, which is the starkness and even gentle cynicism through said starkness and modernity. We don't even see the match get lighted; it's already lit as soon as the wolf dips into frame, and the "puff" sound accompanying the arson is as anticlimactic as the action itself. It's all in the name of business. Freleng's frankness in direction and humor is genuinely laudable. Especially when the action is timed so succinctly--something that is truly difficult to convey through text and images alone.

Frank as the action is, it lingers, emotionally and physically: the following cut still has the puffs of smoke billowing into the atmosphere. A reminder of what was lost and a symbol of the pigs' vulnerability.
In this shot, everything feels suspended. The consequences of the wolf burning their house down. The pigs' lack of defenses. Freleng plays this carefully and concisely, milking every little moment--the click of the door as it opens, the wolf popping his head in, the pigs recoiling. The slow steps rightward from each party. Stalling's musical accompaniment is scored at a crawl to accompany this and vice versa. Even the slow, lugubrious moments are as stunning and effective as the high octane flashbangs of action. The creep of the music and the animation is very, very palpable.
Especially considering it rises in a steady crescendo. The wolf's footsteps forward grow bigger, the pigs' steps backwards broader. The music gently quickens to match. The camera seems to cover a little more ground a little faster. And this builds and builds and builds in careful, measured increments. Eventually, the pigs manage to turn their bodies around the other way. The wolf's posing grows comparatively more aggressive. Both parties are still bound by the restraint in the music and direction, keeping them at this cordial, tense standstill. The build-up is agonizingly tangible; exactly as it should be.
Freleng's execution of this entire moment is masterful, but that's not its only calling. It's funny, too. The sudden synchronization between all three parties in their stilted, cordial power walk is so deliciously unnatural. A precariously balanced farce that the pigs, the wolf, and especially the audience knows will fall apart and give way to the meat of the chase--which is indeed the case.
At least for the two pigs. The wolf pursues them in his own stilted rhythm still, to the point that it becomes his folly; though the matchstick house had no bones, its doorframe is a happy exception.
A brilliant maneuver from Freleng and Maltese. We're meant to have forgotten the door and this failed experiment of a house, discarded so unceremoniously--its arrival comes as a surprise, but it really shouldn't be. Freleng and Maltese were great at hard, blunt comedy and reveals through an even harder and blunter commitment to basic logic. The house has been here the whole time.

Equal hardened commitment to musical timing, again the theme of the entire short, certainly aids in this gag's effectiveness too. The music zips into its coda upon the wolf's impact, pauses slightly for all the time he's in the air, continues when he reverberates on the ground--the music slow and anticipatory--and resolves with an impact matched physically by the wolf. Very cleanly and cleverly orchestrated. The double exposure effects on the wolf's head shakes are a particularly novel (and effective) way to caricature his reverberations, too. Dry brushing tends to be the default rather than multiple images overlaid atop each other.
Phil Monroe assumes animation duties next, immediately identifiable through the pigs' thick, U shaped eyebrows and pudgy cheeks. Monroe's animation work would show up in three separate animation units within this year alone--Freleng, then Tashlin, and then Clampett's--and his style would remain practically the same in all of them. He brought with him a cuteness from his time in the Jones unit that never left him; a good "issue" to have, as his drawings tend to be incredibly appealing as a result.
This remains true for the scene of the two pigs frantically rebuilding their matchstick house. There are some (understandable) liberties taken: the leftover matches on the ground pop out of frame all together when the house is finally built, but is hardly noticeable. Monroe conveys the flurry of activity swiftly and cleanly and serviceably. We've already watched--part of--the house be built before. There's no need for an extended re-introduction or rehash of prior actions. It's about the idea of the pigs building shelter to hide from the wolf in a moment of tenseness, and how that fits into the broader flow of the story.
Very comfortably. This tangent exists solely as a continuation of the first go-around with the matchstick house--same destruction, same outcome, different perpetrator. The unceremoniousness of the wolf's entry adds an extra grain of salt in the wound with how matter of fact and objective his destruction feels. As we learned last time, all it takes is one little match.
The pigs appear nonplussed rather than fearful for this same reason. Another welcome little dose of cynicism and bite to the short's tone and its subversion. 
Of course, it's all in the name of a delayed reaction. Stalling builds up with an anticipatory, swelling crescendo, one that's unleashed in tandem of the pigs' darting away. Their zipping along the trail remains admirably anchored to the melody: the music scoops with a glissando upon each pig's entry, per the music. 
The wolf receives the same whistling flourish on top, despite not fitting in as snugly as the musical structure with the pigs'. That in itself establishes another pattern; there's Brahms' musical structure, and then Freleng and Stalling's to complete the rule of three's.  
Freleng touts a serviceable but refreshing dimensionality between the characters and their environments. Trees and bushes painted on cel overlays to give depth and visual interest to the scene. The pigs--plus one--taking refuge behind a rock. It all isn't particularly intricate, but doesn't need to be. Just a healthy reminder that these environments are lived in and interactive rather than two dimensional set pieces.
Likewise with the wolf chasing after the pigs, all of the characters darting into the horizon that sneaks up on the viewer just as much as the wolf did the pigs. A nice sudden flurry of activity and perspective to keep the momentum going and the visual interest alive. That too is seconded with Stalling's orchestration, the chords and notes arranged slightly different than before to give this scene a sense of acceleration.
Too much acceleration, in the wolf's case: continuity with the door slams furthers the feeling of structure, momentum, and story within the short through this recall. That, and it's funny. Its presence as a repeated topper has since become the joke, rather than the wolf getting a door to the face. This will continue.
Especially with the wolf slamming his body into the door repeatedly, dutifully timed to the middle section of the 6th Hungarian Dance. A long, silent pause persists in the time that he's on the ground and the wind-up--it milks the suspense of the action, the audience waiting for the inevitably burst of music and action alike, but is especially noticeable considering its deviation from this short's patterning of music. This is a big moment.
Or, Freleng and Maltese would like for us to think so, anyway; the wolf was able to fell a house with a single matchstick both times. Now, slamming all of his body weight and resorting to the tried and true huff-and-puff (which in itself feels like a last resort--following typical convention, in this short, is a pis aller), the house doesn't budge an inch. Obviously, given the familiar story of the fairytale, but the climaxing, aggressive music is more reflective of the wolf's increasing ire and desperation rather than any anxiety on the pigs' behalf, which is how it's seemed to favor thus far. The pigs are a non-entity for this scene. We're merely watching a humiliation ritual on behalf of the wolf. That in itself feels very indicative of the subversive, dry humor brought by the Freleng-Maltese team-ups.
Dick Bickenbach animates this humiliation ritual beautifully. Drybrushed multiples on the wolf sell the effect of his reverberations with each knock-back. Just the same, his animation isn't reliant on additional flourishes like drybrushing and impact lines when kicking the door--the limberness of his posing and timing alike all pull their equal share. This section of music is harsh, choppy, abrasive, and needs animation with synonymous qualities. Bickenbach was probably the best candidate for the job with how naturally spry his work is. Great casting by Freleng.
On the topic of this short's creative influences, Mike Maltese's presence is certifiably felt in the follow-up gag: one of the pigs wordlessly offering a jug of mouthwash counteracting the wolf's implicitly bad breath.
The integration of such a modern convenience is again very Maltese-ian in itself, but it's likewise a recurring gag: the same joke with the same context was first used in 1940's A Gander at Mother Goose. Though Ben Hardaway received the story credit for that short, his cornpone, hayseed humor isn't felt very strongly in that one. As there was still a pool of writers at the time, it's very well possible that Maltese suggested the mouthwash gag in that cartoon--especially considering Maltese has been on record about the comedic monopoly Hardaway had as the head writer, the two of them often butting heads as Hardaway would freeze him out.
As expected, the gag is much more succinct in its usage here, in timing and execution: the mere close-up painting of the bottle, completely static, no additional animation as in the case of Gander, pulls all the heavy lifting. Blunt and funny. Likewise with the wolf wordlessly slapping it out of the pig's hand, his rejection as clear as the punchline. Comparing both gags back to back yields impressive results in just how snappy the studio's timing of cartoons has grown in only three years.
All in service of moving onto the next piece of business: the wolf trying again to bust down the door. His movements are much more deliberate and calculated this time, in accordance to the slow, contemplative music and to milk the anticipation of his action. His footsteps meticulously anchoring to the ground with each music note seems to drag out the suspense even further than if he had retreated along normally--it's unnatural, it's deliberate, and antithetical to the instinct of just running for it. With all of this build-up, we know there's going to be an equal and opposite reaction: when, not if. It's the ambiguity of the when that is so effective here.
Knowing this, Freleng lures the audience in a brilliant fake-out. The wolf's musically inclined running entry, hopping and straining to the beat without breaking an iota of forward momentum--the background pan cheated as well, as the distance he covers running towards the house is twice as long as from when he retreated--comes to an equally deliberate and delicate halt:
Stalling suspending his music score completely as the wolf measures himself pushes an already great gag over the edge. Another decidedly Malteseian touch of humor with its meticulous, mundane domesticity played for an explosive reaction.
Likewise, it's a clever way for Freleng to get economical with footage and pencil mileage: Dick Bickenbach's animation can be reused exactly under the guise of a parallel structure, completing a missing tangent, and greatly supported by the musicality's structure as well. It doesn't feel cheap or lazy here, as it may have the potential to in a non-musically oriented cartoon.
Especially considering the pattern is subverted at the last second. When the audience anticipates the wolf to launch into the same galloping run as he had before, Freleng instead cuts to one of the pigs gregariously opening the door. The disingenuous, coy expression on the pig is able to communicate so much with so little, particularly his avoidant eye contact as the wolf cluelessly gallavants past. (Side note: another sign of the short's Disney aping is the framed portrait of "Uncle Ham, which is perhaps even more to the point than the Disney cartoon's portrait of "father".)
More parallel structure with the second pig holding another door. Same coy expression with the same communication that the wolf is going to get his. 
Such is exacted in the final cut, obeying the rule of three's: where two doors open, one closes--right in the wolf's face.
A simple but incredibly effective sequence through its straightforwardness. To fluff it up with extreme theatrics would muddy the clarity and execution and intent; the bluntness of the door slam and the lack of reactivity from the pigs enhances the violence of the action much more than any over-the-top, exaggerated distortion could. Likewise, the simplicity calls attention to the parallel structure, which is as rhythmic in execution as the actual music beneath. Funny and to the point, subverting the door slam gag so as to keep the repetition from getting stale, but still clearly in the same family as the other instances. 
Another brief note of admiration: each shot of each pig is somewhat color coordinated. The green wallpaper in the first shot is analogous with the pig's blue sweater, the magenta walls in the second shot matches the second pig's sweater, and the red floors of the kitchen in the third coordinates with the practical pig's hat. Since these shots fly by so quickly, the color coordination helps to unify the visuals and ensure the audience isn't overloaded with too much visual information at one time. Likewise, the interior of the house itself is quite modern--colorful wallpaper, decorative drapes, chairs and portraits, shiny kitchen utilities; a deliberate departure from the barebones house interiors in the Disney cartoon. Another subtle but cumulative example of this cartoon's insurgent modernity. Even something as menial as the milk bottle on the outside stoop upholds the idea.

Going back to the topic of continuity and parallel structure, said continuity doesn't get more clear than a direct reprise of the pigs' musical gallivanting... plus one.
This scene may be the single best encapsulation of the short's ethos: the sharpness of the musical timing, animation principals, and character acting, as expounded upon previously, but also the bludgeon of impish cynicism through the third pig's objective vexation. He almost seems to serve as a stand-in for Freleng himself, who perhaps regarded the Disney cartoon the same way the pig regards his brothers. Perhaps that's an uncharitable read, as there has to be some level of admiration and respect for the original to strike up such an involved and spectacular lampoon as this one. Nevertheless, it's exceedingly clear that the practical pig represents the subversive, playful, sardonic attitudes cultivated by the Warner cartoons. 
Likewise, his acting is as pronounced as his brothers' dancing--big, dramatic heaves of the chest as he sighs, the deliberation in which he rubs his face; it's still incidental enough not to detract focus from the main subjects at hand, but it deliberately calls attention to its own cynicism. We're meant to sympathize with him with a tongue squarely in our cheeks. 
Of course, cynical pigs or no cynical pigs, the wolf remains hungry and determined--and now, crafty. The camera slides away from these gay antics and over to the window, easing the audience into the re-introduction of the wolf: now, as a poorly beggar.
Again with the parallel structure for the sake of continuity and, with it, clear, intentional directing: Freleng employs a match-cut (or just about; the framing isn't one-to-one, but doesn't need to be) of the window, with the two impressionable pigs looking out where the wolf was just looking in.
Viewers suspicious of a sudden snowstorm on such a sunny day would be correct: a tried and true gag that Mike Maltese would enjoy using again in Little Orphan Airedale, we reveal to see that the storm--metaphorical/emotional and "literal"--is entirely man-made. 
The wolf is turned away from the window rather than looking in as he was before--both to match his position in his prior cut (as he was facing left there, too) and to communicate a certain detachment. To be turned inwards to the house may come off as too desperate, too needy to come in. An additional, pathetic pathos is upheld by him being the one to shun himself away.
And, as with the Airedale usage in the future, the wolf shudders to initiate a heavier flow of talcum snow. Here, it arrives with the benefit and genius of musical timing, the shudder embodying the shuddering trill of the strings in the score. Likewise, the talcum powder is softened through the airbrushing, which gives the visuals an even greater believability and certain prestige through the differentiation in texture. The wolf casting his eyes up at the powder as he does his shakes adds a gentle layer of meta awareness on top, demonstrating the consciousness--and coyness--of his acting decisions.
Equally coy (on Freleng and Maltese's behalf, both with their wry senses of humor) is the instantaneous tear drops from both pigs, won over by this pitiful display. Freleng's staging continues to impress: both pigs remain divided by the window pane, separated into their respective corners, something most visible when they turn to look at each other. It's a small detail, but one that really elevates the visual interest of a somewhat inherently flat bit of staging. Freleng wasn't exactly known for his inventive shot framing, so to see some exceptions sneak through are certainly worth pointing out. It contributes to the aforementioned "prestige" of this sequence which, of course, is relating to the entire short.
Phil Monroe proves a great candidate for the following scene in which the two brothers happily resolve to help the wolf-in-babushka's-clothing--their joyous bumbling over to the door is lively, full of character, and, most importantly, cute. 
Which makes for quite the contrast when the practical pig--already barricading the door, revealed simply through a camera pan, which is a nice consolidation of action on Freleng's behalf and makes for a bigger surprise felt on behalf of the other two pigs--literally shuts them out. The other brothers were so happy and carefree; to rain on their parade would practically be cruelty.
Though, in actuality, it's the other two pigs exacting the cruelty, specifically #2 as he promptly pushes his brother aside. Another wonderful differentiation from the Disney cartoon, where this sibling rivalry and blunt "violence" would never be tolerated. The playful cynicism of Freleng and Maltese's tones are delightfully strong here; especially with the pronounced "thunk" from Treg Brown as the pig is pushed. With the whole scene in pantomime, the addition of this sound--solely to enunciate the roughhousing--is a punchline in itself.
More strong framing as the practical pig hides behind the door on one half of the screen, separated by his brothers helping the wolf in from the other half. Good visual equilibrium and a strong visual metaphor for where each pigs' allegiances lie.
Though the practical pig doesn't remain entirely behind un-closed doors. The act put on by the wolf is just convincing enough for him to weaken into curious pity. Good, communicative acting from Monroe, again all in mere pantomime. The pig adjusting his hat from slipping off of his face as he skips over to join his brothers is another nice touch of character--necessary? Not exactly, but appreciated. Likewise, it serves as a parallel to the other two brothers grabbing their respective hats upon their respective scrambles.
Any pity that the third pig has is quick to last. With an expression of determined concentration, he opts to investigate matters, done so in a confidential close-up just between himself and (the back of) the wolf.
Thus, the discovery of the record player strapped to the wolf's back, is known only to him. This too is a tried and true gag, and can be traced as far back as the Harman-Ising era for Warner's in particular (Bosko's Mechanical Man), but its antiquity doesn't negate its effectiveness. The sheen of Monroe's draftsmanship and the tone constructed by Freleng keep it fairly modern, but especially considering the gentle solution through subversion.
Rather than exposing the wolf and ridding himself of the record player all together, the pig merely flips to its B side. The discrepancy in music pins all of the blame right back on the wolf, forced to adapt to his own hubris rather than be stripped of it all together. The former option is more humiliating. Such is communicated through the gleefully mischievous grin on the pig right before the cut.
"Before the cut" is of particular note--the music doesn't burst back from the melancholic 17th Hungarian Dance to the brash, peppy 5th until after the cut. Doing so makes the reveal feel more sudden, shocking, forward, both on behalf of the audience and certainly on behalf of the now-confused wolf.
As mentioned above, the wolf is forced to adapt, assimilating to a belated reprise of his Hopak--it's a bigger humiliation ritual than if all of his resources were stripped together at all. Especially when it's the wolf doing the stripping; his disguise is gradually shed from the efforts. The parallel to his traipsing in the woods is never more clear than when he's fully "undressed". Motion and even the idea of the clothes coming off of him is pretty reliant on caricaturing and cheating, as the movement is relatively unnatural, but this is an action bent on caricature. Him shedding his disguise is representative of a shift in story, and quite a damning one, rather than any attempt at hyperrealistic clothing physics. The wolf has infiltrated the pigs' home, and there are no more false pretenses in his motives.
Again, Freleng feels no need to artificially fluff up the circumstances. No big moment of creeping, dreadful realization, not even a confrontation: just a swift transition into the climax, all characters almost mechanically--in a metatextual, self aware way--assuming their given roles. Predator versus prey.
Such is felt in the shot of the three pigs running up the stairs, packed together in one single unit, melting down the chase dynamic into its barest essentials. Another hallmark of Maltese's writing. Likewise, rather significant, as all three brothers are on equal footing--no more two against one. The subtle shift in perspective is incredibly artful and elevates the visual interest of the scene. Its staging isn't reliant on geography, so much as it is feeling and motion. It's about feeling the momentum rather than where that momentum is being fostered.
Adding to that, the camera doesn't entirely follow the pigs: after a point, the stairs swallow the screen. Viewers are suddenly disconnected from the action and an ideal sense of unease is born through the uncertainty.
The same exact tricks are employed for the wolf (sans perspective shift): same motion, same layout, same timing to communicate the ultimate parallel. Feelings of the wolf gaining on them are caricatured even through the filmmaking patterns--it's more anxiety inducing to see him follow the exact same path and momentum as the pigs, because it makes them both equals, and that means trouble for the pigs. Prey does not want to have equal momentum to the predator: it needs much, much more.
One of the most impressive feats of musical timing unfolds in the ensuing shot. High praise, considering how sharply attuned this cartoon's timing is all over: a sudden reveal to another room in the house. The pigs enter through one door, movements unified, their symmetry allowing for better visual clarity.
Then the wolf enters. Same timing. Same motion. Different door.
Practical Pig does a take in tandem with an emphasized music sting.
His brothers take right behind him, on the second sting.
The wolf on the third. He's just as surprised to see his company as they are him.
Tip-top timing continues into the next shot: now, the two emphasized music chords score the two pigs running through the door. The third follows their third.
And, of course, the floaty, airy resolution of the music scores the lovably familiar act of the wolf slamming into the door. It's the same lovably familiar music chord, too. The ardent faithfulness of the timing and the excitement of the climax again prevents the gag from getting stale, as does the subversion with this being a Dutch door the wolf slams into. This time, he only has himself to blame.

The final burst of the cartoon goes particularly heavy on the short's subversion: with all the discussion of modernity in this cartoon, it doesn't get more modern nor convenient than an elevator right in the pigs' hoe, introduced with utmost nonchalance. The same could even be said for the potted plant right outside of it. Suddenly, the pig's home--this same, humble, practical house built of bricks--is transformed into a hotel lobby.
Confidently convoluted convenience isn't questioned; just merely accepted as all pigs pile into the elevator. A cymbal crash scores the music, in tandem with another surprise take from the pig, reinstilling any urgency that may have been lost in service of laughs at the elevator's convenience. A reminder that the wolf is hot on their trail, no matter what the surroundings look like.
Indeed. In parallel structure, just like the repeated stairway shots, the wolf piles into the elevator himself...
...thusly giving Maltese's writing to strike with another pet favorite trope of his: absurdity and comedy through rigid adherence to logic. Surely you didn't think the elevator had already come back up to the current floor--we just saw the pigs take it down. So, logically, no elevator.
Not physically, at least. What could be an easy opportunity for a Wile E. Coyote-esque pratfall is instead sacrificed for the wolf taking his "elevator" down, completely ignorant to the improbability. The convolution better supports the music, of course, hence its choosing over a sudden drop from the wolf, but the unquestioning leisure in which this convolution unfolds is where most of the laughs hit. Particularly the acting on the wolf. Idly removing his hat, thoughtlessly looking upwards as he bides his time.
It's funny, but it's practical just the same and still manages to feel climactic. The wolf gradually outpaces the camera, slowly traveling down the shot to make the momentum more tangible and, with it, his impending doom. Stalling and Freleng add onto that with the anticipatory growl of the music, deep bass notes rising in an anticipatory crescendo, the strings frantic and hurried. It's a matter of when, not if, that the wolf will crash, and Freleng successfully milks the suspense and keeps the audience bracing; something that makes the inevitable impact all the more effective.
Something that also makes the impact more effective: obscuring it completely. We never actually see the wolf smash to the ground proper... but the camera shake, deafening crash sound effects, and emphatic musical chord paint a joyously visceral picture. A frequent philosophy stated time and time again on this blog: the viewer's imagination is limitless, whereas an impact drawn on-screen is only as strong as the drawings themselves. The ambiguity inherent in leaving it up to the audience is perhaps stronger than any impact drawing could be. The imagination, if only subconscious, is a very powerful thing. Especially when supported by helpful directorial facets as mentioned above.
Considering the intensity of the camera shake and sound effects, that the wolf only lumbers out with a shiner on his head is pretty good given the circumstances. Even with his delightfully punch-drunk walk, him dazedly returning the hat to his head (which is another point of genius; not only was him holding his hat a fun visual gag of added humanity and domesticity, but also so that we could see the lump on his head), the viewer gets the idea that there's something more to come out of this.
There is. A final topple as the cartoon's topper.
Even something as menial as the cartoon's iris-out receives the same dignity of a sprightly, bouncy, aptly timed iris out. Wolf falls on beat one, iris focuses on beat two, overshoots and closes for good on beat three.

Per the Film Daily upon the short's release (and another thank you to Yowp for his efforts in archiving these):

"Pigs in a Polka" (Merrie Melodie)
Warner 7 Mins. Musical Treat
The main attraction here is not so much what meets the eye as what greets the ear. This is not to say that the animation is not first-rate and amusing. It just so happens that the music of Brahms runs throughout the film, providing a lovely accompaniment to the action, which concerns a battle of wits between the Three Little Pigs and the Big Bad Wolf. The wolf, naturally, loses out. The cartoon, a Technicolor item, is an excellent wedding of humor and music. Musical Director Carl W. Stalling merits a nod.

"The main attraction here is not so much what meets the eye as what greets the ear" is perhaps the greatest way to sum up the cartoon in one single sentence, though, personally, this author believes what meets the eye is pretty darn good, too--and so did the reviewer in the following sentence.

"Masterpiece" is a word that's all too easy to overuse all too flippantly, completely dehydrating it of any meaning. What's a masterpiece if everything is? But, truly, this short deserves every accolade and more. As mentioned in the introduction, this short innately receives comparisons to Bob Clampett's A Corny Concerto, and not unfoundedly so. There are a number of debates on which is the "better" cartoon--something, again, that'll be touched on in the Concerto review--Concerto is perhaps the slight inverse of the above hypothesis, in that what meets the eye is slightly more than what meets the ear. Freleng isn't renowned for his fluffy, bombastic visual style, and this cartoon has a tendency to come off as underplayed in comparison to the visual bombasm of Concerto.

Polka is technical. Technical, but not devoid of spirit or humor in the slightest. Its appeal doesn't just start and end with how stringent the musical timing is. It's very well structured, it's charming, and it's certainly funny, whether through the slapstick, the personality animation, the outright rejection of Disneyana, the dry, cynical comedy and narrative voice concocted by Freleng and Maltese alike, or the metatextual commentary tying into the previous points. 

This isn't just a Fantasia where the appeal is merely the spectacle. For certain, this is an unconventional cartoon. It feels like it has more prestige than a "typical" Freleng unit cartoon, or even the shorts by his contemporaries; it's clear this was a labor of love and an extraordinary (in the literal sense of the word) amount of dedication was poured into the cartoon. But it's not a fluff piece. It's not pretentious. It's the complete opposite, and that's its strength.

Freleng's "prequel" piece to this, the similarly impressive Rhapsody in Rivets, has been dubbed by some as the working-class Fantasia; Polka observes a similar line of thought. A cartoon of this nature has the capacity to be incredibly obnoxious through any pretense of pretension, which is why the cartoon deliberately opens with a damning destruction--not deconstruction--of such. The wolf doing a hack job as a Deems Taylor-wannabe (and we don't even get the sense that he wants to be a wannabe), butchering the pronunciation, including of the composer's name, colloquially bloviating by putting himself above the pigs; the attempts to be formal and prestigious fail spectacularly, and that's the point. It's both funny to watch but also representative of Freleng's intent with the cartoon: the exertion and dedication to the craft is very real, but it's not very serious and doesn't need to be. 

The no-nonsense, dry, blunt tone of Freleng's direction works to this short's favor even beyond the comedy--the objectivity allows for greater focus on the musical timing, as the audience isn't too distracted by the animation overpowering the music. There are no frills to get tangled up and lost in. The wolf doesn't get "shot" and have a dramatic death fake-out where the pigs sob rhythmically over his crumpled up corpse, but each and every door slam and pratfall almost feels even more violent because of how much more grounded it is. Especially when Freleng uses the gag continuity as a structural beam within the cartoon itself, so that the use of the gag becomes the gag itself. A lack of frills allows for such unfettered focus to be divvied unto these technicalities, and works brilliantly to the cartoon's favor.

This is an easy 5-star cartoon to this author, personally, and a genuine gold standard of how to turn every single musical note into a gag itself. The musicality and the gags are absolutely intrinsic, but not to the point of getting lost in themselves. It feels like all the years of Freleng's musical prowess and timing have built up to make this cartoon--and would continue to do so, as he certainly wasn't done with his musical masterpieces yet. Three Little Bops deserves as much comparison to this cartoon as A Corny Concerto, a fascinating specimen to compare in regards to how it was made in such a drastically different time period and studio culture. Rhapsody Rabbit is on the level of Polka in terms of musical masterpieces that are as funny as they are impressive. Freleng still had a lot of musical and comedic genius ahead of him to dispel, but this short does set an almost unattainable standard. Practically everything just feels as though it was done right, even if it's not particularly flashy. That's why everything was done right. 

This short deserves every ounce of its Oscar nomination and, like Rivets, deserves to have won, yet again losing out to Disney with Der Feuhrer's Face (which, in fairness, is a very significant cartoon)--there's certainly some delightful irony to be had in the short poking fun at Disney and rejecting their humor losing out to them. But this cartoon's underdog nature is what makes it so compelling--the scrappiness, the brutality, the cynicism--and maybe it was meant to maintain that role in a broader scheme. After all, the lack of pretension and frills is what makes this such a success. 

393. Pigs in a Polka (1943)

Release Date : February 2nd, 1943 Series : Merrie Melodies Director : Friz Freleng Story : Mike Maltese Animation : Dick Bickenbach Musical ...