All Bosko cartoons I review could also benefit from this disclaimer, but disclaimer: seeing as this is the first entry in the Censored 11, this review contains racist imagery, content, and stereotypes. I don’t in any way endorse these, nor do I take pleasure displaying them on my blog. However, it would be wrong of me to gloss over this and act like it didn’t happen, and that everything’s fine. These are issues that need to be discussed and can’t be shoved under the rug. This is purely for informational and educational purposes. If there’s anything I can do to make this easier to get through, PLEASE let me know, and PLEASE correct me if I say anything offensive or hurtful. Your enjoyment and your comfort are my priority, and I don’t want to squander that because of a careless mistake. Thank you for understanding and I hope this can serve as an educational source of information.
Release date: November 28th, 1931
Series: Merrie melodies
Director: Rudolf Ising
Starring: Johnny Murray (Piggy), Rudolf Ising (Alligator, Villain), Ken Darby (Uncle Tom), The King's Men (Chorus)
As I mentioned above, this is the first entry in the infamous Censored 11 list. For some background information, the Censored 11 is a group of cartoons held from syndication starting in 1968, because the use of ethnic stereotypes (specifically black stereotypes) was too offensive to show to audiences. (In my opinion that list should be WAYYY longer, but I digress.) In this cartoon, Piggy tries to rescue a kidnapped Fluffy on a steamboat, whereas an epithetical, doglike Uncle Tom is terrorized by skeletons in a graveyard. A steamboat and some skeletons, certainly sounds familiar, doesn’t it?
The cartoon opens with three blackface caricatures playing the eponymous song “Hittin’ the Trail for Hallelujah Land” on a banjo, mouth harp, and spoons. The song is catchy with some beautiful layered harmonies, though the caricatures make it hard to appreciate.
We get a shot of the steamboat they’re aboard on the moonlit water. I’m sure you can tell, but this time we’re ripping off Disney with Steamboat Willie (it gets less subtle in a minute). However, I love the above gag of the steamboat heading down the waterfall. The backgrounds are quite moody and beautiful, too. I love moonlit backgrounds though, especially in black and white cartoons.
Now we see why this is in the Censored 11 (if the blackface wasn’t enough). Fluffy happens to be riding on a horse drawn (donkey drawn, really) cart with a doglike Uncle Tom epithet, both of them giving a few lyric-less bars of “Camptown Races” in the style of Foghorn Leghorn. A whistle sounds, and Fluffy urges “Oh, there’s the boat! Hurry, Uncle Tom!” Uncle Tom whips the donkey and they race off.
Ahh, subtlety! Mickey Piggy is the captain of the steamboat, dancing while ringing various bells and horns to the beat of the underscored music.
Fluffy and Uncle Tom arrive just in time for the steamboat to dock. Fluffy boards the boat, leaving Piggy tasked with carrying her heavy luggage that briefly dips him into the water as the bridge sags beneath its weight.
Fluffy bids Uncle Tom farewell, and the passengers dance and clap along to the jazz band blaring out a tune. Piggy and Fluffy are also dancing, but Piggy, being the intelligent porcine he is, is perched right on the edge of the boat.
He predictably falls off, landing on the paddled wheels which smack him repeatedly before sending him flying. He then lands on an alligator, mistaking it for a rock.
Dodging the alligator’s snapping jaws, he swims to a nearby log, plucks a twig off the side and plants it in his butt to use as a propeller. He hugs the log and speeds away, losing the alligator and climbing back to safety. Amusing gag, but highly predictable.
Focus is back on Uncle Tom, who’s back on the carriage with the donkey. Perpetuating the stereotype of black people being “lazy”, he’s asleep. The donkey’s tail occasionally hits him, causing him to wake up and go back to sleep. Tired of getting swatted at, Tom ties a rock to the tail of the donkey. The donkey is undeterred and hits him on the head with the rock, which sends him flying, landing conveniently in a nearby graveyard. Honestly, this entire sequence is more cringeworthy and uncomfortable than it is funny.
As Uncle Tom frightfully roams the graveyard, a mausoleum opens up to reveal a swarm of bats, followed by a gang of singing skeletons.
Uncle Tom and the skeletons engage in a call and response musical number, singing “Hittin’ the Trail for Hallelujah Land”. The singing is good, but once more hard to appreciate with Uncle Tom right there, not to mention this is a blatant ripoff of Disney’s The Skeleton Dance. And man, to think that Chuck Jones’ early cartoons were Disneyesque! Gags include a tiny skeleton dog rising from a grave and barking, receiving a swift kick by a skeleton back into the grave.
Justifiably terrified, Uncle Tom escapes the graveyard by diving through a hole in the crumbling brick wall. He spots a boat on the ground, and à la Fred Flintstone picks it up and runs, diving into the lake. However, because there’s no bottom, it’s useless, and he swims away. I DO enjoy that gag (as much as I can), stereotypical in the usage of the gag but amusing nonetheless.
More stereotypes as we find out that Uncle Tom can’t swim. Cut back to Piggy and Fluffy, who hear his cries for help. Piggy heroically declares “I’ll save Uncle Tom!” and dives off the side of the boat...
...straight out of his Mickey Mouse patented pants. He swims back in the air to get them, diving back in the water. Again, another funny gag, but it has more potential than humor to it. In my opinion, My Favorite Duck uses the same gag much more effectively.
Enter the Tex Avery villain (not actually Tex Avery, he wouldn’t come aboard until 1935, but this type of villain would be used in many of his shorts, like The Blow Out and Milk and Money). The villain kidnaps Fluffy, and Piggy, already tasked with saving Uncle Tom (who he’s dragging to shore) has to swoop in to the rescue.
Piggy scales a passing mail hook and snatches Fluffy to safety, leaving the vaudevillian dangling by his coat on the hook.
But that’s not all! Piggy teaches the villain a lesson by lowering the hook above a conveniently placed buzz saw, torturing the villain and cutting his ass open. Jesus! Piggy and Fuffy embrace and laugh merrily as the torture ensues. Iris out.
Well... where to begin? Obviously, this one was uncomfortable to get through. It’s unfortunate but also true—this is the tamest of the Censored 11. I found myself cringing and constantly thinking about the stereotypes, and because of that I had a hard time appreciating any positive elements, such as bits of good animation and a swingy music score. The stereotypes were there, but sadly pale in comparison as to some of the things we’ll be seeing... but we’ll cross that bridge when we get there.
Uncomfortableness aside with the content, this short itself was pretty boring and not very funny. The backgrounds were nice and moody, and I enjoyed the music, but that’s about it. (Watch at your own discretion of course, it wouldn’t be right of me not to link this and act like it doesn’t exist.)
No comments:
Post a Comment